Crazy Aaron'sStandard
24K Real Gold |Thinking Putty
$400
Brand value guide
Crazy Aaron's Value Guide
Every Crazy Aaron's squishy fidget variant we track, sorted by current resale value — most valuable first. 101 variants in this brand, topping out around $400. Values and price history refresh daily so you always know what each one is really worth.
Filter & sort all Crazy Aaron's in the browser →Read the Most Valuable Crazy Aaron's guide →
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty (5pc)
$90
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Mini Tins Lot
$65
Crazy Aaron'sRare
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Limited Edition Solar Wind
$49.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Lost Treasure Guardians Complete Set
$49
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Mini Tins Assorted
$47.99
Crazy Aaron'sRare
Aaron Crazy Valentines Thinking Putty
$47
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking Putty Lost Treasure GuardiansUncommon
Thinking Putty Lost Treasure Guardians Complete Set (10-Pack)
$44.10
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Bundle (2pc)
$44
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Scaredy Cat
$35
Crazy Aaron's · Better Butter Thinking PuttyStandard
Better Butter Buttercream Thinking Putty Tin
$34
Crazy Aaron'sUncommon
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Limited Edition Jingle
$29.99
Crazy Aaron'sUncommon
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Limited Edition Jack O'Lantern
$29.99
Crazy Aaron'sUncommon
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Limited Edition Robins Egg
$29.99
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
North Star Thinking Putty
$29.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty North Star
$27.50
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Jack O Lantern
$27.50
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aaron’s Better Butter Thinking Putty Sensory Fidget Putty
$25.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aaron’s Better Butter Berry Thinking Putty Sensory Fidget Putty
$25.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Mystic Crystal | MINI
$256.3× retail
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Thinking Putty
$25
Crazy Aaron's · Better Butter Thinking PuttyStandard
Better Butter Berry Butter Thinking Putty Tin
$25
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Creator | Kit
$25
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Boba | Mixed by Me Kit
$25
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking Putty MiniStandard
Mini Thinking Putty Fidget Toys Bundle (4-Pack)
$25
Crazy Aaron'sGrail
Super Rare Retired Burmese Ruby Thinking Putty
$23
Crazy Aaron's · Viral Mystery DumplingUncommon
Viral Mystery Shark Squishy Dumpling
$20.30
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Eggcellent Thinking Putty
$19.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Mini Thinking Putty Super Oil Slick
$19.95
Crazy Aaron'sUncommon
Aaron's Crazy Better Butter Thinking Putty
$16.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Cosmic Star Dust
$16
Crazy Aaron'sUncommon
Aurora Sky | Glowbrights
$15
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty Eggcellent Tin
$15
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Thinking Putty Eggcellent 2.1 oz Tin
$15
Crazy Aaron'sUncommon
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Liquid Glass Falling Water
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Better Butter | Trendsetters
$15
Crazy Aaron's · Better Butter Thinking PuttyStandard
Better Butter 3.5" Thinking Putty Tin
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Brown Sugar Boba | Trendsetters
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Comic Book | Thinking Putty
$15
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Glow in the Dark Mermaid Tale Thinking Putty
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Blooming Botanicals | Trendsetters
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
BFF | Trendsetters
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Cookie Cutter | Thinking Putty
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Amazing Axolotl | Trendsetters
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Baby Elephant |Trendsetters
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Buttercream Better Butter | Trendsetters
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Arcade Adventure | Hide Inside!
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Camo | Thinking Putty
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Better Butter Berry | Trendsetters
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Christmas Classics | Bundle
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Strange Attractor
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Super Scarab
$15
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Falling Water
$14.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aaron's Putty Mini Tins Gift Set Sunburst
$14.95
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Mini Sparkle Thinking Putty Icicle
$14.95
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking Putty TreasureStandard
Thinking Putty Treasure Peel to Reveal Set (3-Pack)
$14.25
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aaron's Better Butter Thinking Putty Aaron's Crazy
$14
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aaron's Golden Honeycomb Putty Honey Hive
$13.50
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking Putty Egg CellentStandard
Egg Cellent Thinking Putty
$13.50
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Mixed Emotions Multicolor
$12.99
Crazy Aaron's · Better Butter Thinking PuttyStandard
Better Butter Thinking Putty
$12
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Cosmic Matter | Water Slime | Slime Charmers
$12
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Cereal O' Clock | Buttery Slime | Slime Charmers
$12
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Christmas 2" Fidget Three Pack
$12
Crazy Aaron's · SCENTsory PuttyStandard
SCENTsory Putty Scoopberry
$10
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Curious Kitten
$10
Crazy Aaron's · SCENTsory PuttyStandard
SCENTsory Putty Snackerjack
$10
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Intergalactic
$10
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aaron’s Hide Inside! Party Animals Thinking Putty – Find-It Fidget Sensory Putty
$9.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aarons Comic Book Thinking Putty – Superhero Fidget Sensory Putty
$9.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aaron’s Birthstone Thinking Putty – Shimmering Sensory Fidget Putty
$9.99
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking Putty MiniStandard
Mini Thinking Putty Sushi Pickleball Ketchup & Mustard
$9.71
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking Putty Super ScarabUncommon
Thinking Putty Super Scarab Color Shifting (2.1 oz)
$8.12
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Thinking Putty Challenge Game
$8
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking Putty LargeStandard
Funky Fidget Thinking Putty Large (2.1 oz)
$8
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Bubblegum/Marshmallow | SCENTsory Duos
$8
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Cocoamallow | SCENTsory
$8
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Banana Split | SCENTsory
$8
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Liquid Glass Thinking Putty
$7.99
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Aaron's Crazy Thinking Putty Candy Cane
$6.15
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyStandard
Crazy Aaron's Thinking Putty - Cryptic Carnation
$5
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Be Mine | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Acai Bowl | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Bounce Bot | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Cave of Wonders | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Capybara | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Cryptocurrency | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Campfire | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Blueberry Muffin | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Christmas Tree | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Avocado | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Country Pop | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Candy Cane Lane | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Cotton Candy | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Buzzing Bee | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Blobfish | MINI
$4
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Butterfly | MINI Tin
$4
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking PuttyUncommon
Thinking Putty Blobfish
$3.87
Crazy Aaron's · Thinking Putty MiniStandard
Mini Thinking Putty Assorted
$3.50
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Crazy Aaron Accessory 4 Count Eyeball Pack
$3
Crazy Aaron'sStandard
Bag Clip | Red
$3